Released: May 11, 2018
Songwriter: Johan Carlsson Jacob Kasher Charlie Puth
Producer: Johan Carlsson Charlie Puth
[Verse 1]
I was just with you on your birthday
And I met your whole family
But on the way home
You kept looking at your phone
Couldn't help but ask, "Who is that, babe?"
And the way you said, "Nobody"
I knew the rumors
They were more than just rumors
[Pre-Chorus]
Maybe I should have noticed
You were just half in love
Maybe I should have noticed
That I'm not the only one
[Chorus]
Somebody told me that you
Got another lover you've been giving it to
Can't believe I believed you
You were my girl
Somebody saw you with him
Now you're tryna tell me that he's only a friend
Can't believe I believed it
You were my girl
(Ooh, ooh)
(Ooh, ooh-ooh-ooh)
[Verse 2]
Lately you've been making excuses
And the stories ain't adding up
But I just go blind when you look into my eyes
Every time that I try to confront you (To confront you)
There's always somewhere you gotta run to (Gotta run to)
The warning signs
They were more than just warning signs
[Pre-Chorus]
Maybe I should have noticed
You were just half in love (You were half in love)
Maybe I should have noticed
That I'm not the only one
[Chorus]
'Cause somebody told me that you
Got another lover you've been giving it to
Can't believe I believed you
You were my girl
Somebody saw you with him
Now you're tryna tell me that he's only a friend
Can't believe I believed that
You were my girl
(Ooh, ooh)
(Ooh, ooh-ooh-ooh)
You were my girl
Maybe I should have noticed
You were just half in love (You were half in love)
Maybe I should have noticed
That I'm not the only one (You were my girl)
[Bridge]
Yeah
Maybe I should have noticed
That I'm not the only one
[Chorus]
Somebody told me that you
Got another lover you've been giving it to
Can't believe I believed you (Believed you)
You were my girl
Somebody saw you with him
Now you're tryna tell me that he's only a friend
Can't believe I believed that (Believed that)
You were my girl
That you were mine
Hey, you were my girl
Maybe I should have noticed
You were just half in love (You were just half in love)
Maybe I should have noticed
That I'm not the only one
You were my girl
I was just with you on your birthday
And I met your whole family
But on the way home
You kept looking at your phone
Couldn't help but ask, "Who is that, babe?"
And the way you said, "Nobody"
I knew the rumors
They were more than just rumors
[Pre-Chorus]
Maybe I should have noticed
You were just half in love
Maybe I should have noticed
That I'm not the only one
[Chorus]
Somebody told me that you
Got another lover you've been giving it to
Can't believe I believed you
You were my girl
Somebody saw you with him
Now you're tryna tell me that he's only a friend
Can't believe I believed it
You were my girl
(Ooh, ooh)
(Ooh, ooh-ooh-ooh)
[Verse 2]
Lately you've been making excuses
And the stories ain't adding up
But I just go blind when you look into my eyes
Every time that I try to confront you (To confront you)
There's always somewhere you gotta run to (Gotta run to)
The warning signs
They were more than just warning signs
[Pre-Chorus]
Maybe I should have noticed
You were just half in love (You were half in love)
Maybe I should have noticed
That I'm not the only one
[Chorus]
'Cause somebody told me that you
Got another lover you've been giving it to
Can't believe I believed you
You were my girl
Somebody saw you with him
Now you're tryna tell me that he's only a friend
Can't believe I believed that
You were my girl
(Ooh, ooh)
(Ooh, ooh-ooh-ooh)
You were my girl
Maybe I should have noticed
You were just half in love (You were half in love)
Maybe I should have noticed
That I'm not the only one (You were my girl)
[Bridge]
Yeah
Maybe I should have noticed
That I'm not the only one
[Chorus]
Somebody told me that you
Got another lover you've been giving it to
Can't believe I believed you (Believed you)
You were my girl
Somebody saw you with him
Now you're tryna tell me that he's only a friend
Can't believe I believed that (Believed that)
You were my girl
That you were mine
Hey, you were my girl
Maybe I should have noticed
You were just half in love (You were just half in love)
Maybe I should have noticed
That I'm not the only one
You were my girl